Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (2024)

Key takeaways

  • Debt forgiveness is a process where a creditor pardons a debtor from part or all of their outstanding debt.
  • Various types of debt may qualify for forgiveness.
  • Debt forgiveness can offer relief from overwhelming financial burdens, but it does have downsides.
  • There are alternative options for managing debt.

Whether it’s credit card debt or mortgage debt, the average American is amassing more of it. If you find yourself grappling with overwhelming debt payments, you may be wondering about debt forgiveness.

Whether you’re drowning in student loans, medical bills, tax obligations, mortgage payments or credit card debt, understanding debt forgiveness can be a game changer in your journey toward financial freedom.

How debt forgiveness works

Debt forgiveness, also known as debt relief or debt cancellation, is when a creditor pardons a debtor from part or all of their outstanding debt. Essentially, it can be a way to get out of debt without paying.

Debt forgiveness can happen in various ways, such as negotiated settlements, repayment plans or government programs. The goal is to help people manage their debts and financial stability.

Types of debt forgiveness

The type of debt forgiveness can vary depending on the debt you want forgiven. Here are some common types of debt that might qualify for forgiveness, along with some that usually don’t.

Student loan debt

With the rising costs of education, many graduates face the daunting task of repaying substantial student loans. The average student owes $29,100 in student loan principal.

You may have a few options for student loan debt forgiveness. These depend on your job, where you studied and how much of your loan is already paid off.

For example, if you work in public service or for a nonprofit organization for a certain length of time and make regular payments, the remaining balance might be forgiven through the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program or PSLF. Income-Driven Repayment plans consider your income and family size. These plans can forgive the remaining balance after 20–25 years of reduced payments.

Some states and employers offer help with student loan debt. However, not all student loans qualify for forgiveness, especially private ones. While student loan forgiveness can be a huge relief, it’s critical to understand the details of your particular loan.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (1)

Pros

  • You may be able to pay less on your student loan repayments.
  • Several federal debt forgiveness programs are available.
  • Some career paths may offer specialized forgiveness programs.
  • Even partial forgiveness can provide significant relief.
  • Private student loans typically do not qualify for forgiveness.
  • Forgiveness processes usually take time and are not immediate.
  • Eligibility criteria are stringent.
  • Individuals who have defaulted on loans are generally ineligible for forgiveness.

Medical debt

Unexpected medical expenses can accumulate quickly, leading to overwhelming debt. Fortunately, there are processes to help with this type of debt through medical bill debt forgiveness programs.

If you are struggling with medical debt, reaching out to the medical facility where you incurred the debt is a worthwhile first step. You can inquire about their financial assistance policy, which is often referred to as charity care. These programs typically consider your income when determining eligibility.

In some cases, the hospital may significantly reduce your bill or even forgive it entirely. It is worth noting that nonprofit hospitals are legally required to have assistance policies in place to help those in need.

In 2022, the three major credit bureaus announced changes to how they report medical debt. Paid medical collections are now removed from credit reports. Unpaid medical collections won’t appear on credit reports unless they’ve been in collections for at least a year. Furthermore, medical debts under $500 no longer appear on credit reports. These changes offer relief to individuals burdened by medical debt and lessen its impact on credit scores.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (3)

Pros

  • Even if you do not qualify for complete forgiveness, financial assistance may be available.
  • Medical debt forgiveness is awarded on a sliding scale. There is no set limit for how much you need to earn.
  • If you don’t qualify for forgiveness, there may be ways to get your bill reduced.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (4)

Cons

  • Securing medical debt forgiveness can be time consuming and laborious, with no guaranteed outcomes.
  • You may need to provide the medical institution with documentation like tax returns and pay stubs to prove your need.

Tax debt

Unpaid taxes can result in significant financial strain. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) provides several options for taxpayers facing financial hardship. One common method is the Offer in Compromise (OIC) program, which allows taxpayers to settle their tax debt for less than the full amount owed.

Installment agreements provide another avenue, allowing taxpayers to pay their debt over time in manageable monthly payments. Additionally, the IRS may offer penalty abatement or other forms of relief for eligible individuals.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (5)

Pros

  • Get immediate relief from the burden of owing taxes.
  • Potentially settle your tax debt for less than the full amount owed.
  • Avoid harsh collection actions such as wage garnishment or asset seizure.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (6)

Cons

  • Tax debt forgiveness may have implications for future tax filings, and forgiven debt may be considered taxable income.
  • Engaging with the IRS can be complex and time-consuming, requiring careful consideration of available options and potential drawbacks.

Mortgage debt

Typically, mortgage lenders are reluctant to award mortgage debt forgiveness. However, homeowners struggling to make mortgage payments may qualify for loan modifications, short sales, or foreclosure alternatives through government initiatives or lender programs.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (7)

Pros

  • Avoid foreclosure and its damaging effects on credit.
  • Reduce or eliminate a significant portion of mortgage debt.
  • Get relief from the stress and uncertainty associated with struggling to make mortgage payments.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (8)

Cons

  • Mortgage debt forgiveness may have tax implications, as forgiven debt can be considered taxable income in some cases.
  • Homeowners may face challenges in qualifying for mortgage forgiveness programs and navigating the complex process of negotiating with lenders.

Credit card debt

Credit card forgiveness is a rarity. Credit card issuers typically expect individuals to repay the amount borrowed, and high-interest credit card debt can be difficult to overcome.

Two options to help manage credit card debts include debt settlement negotiations or credit card refinancing (consolidation loans or balance transfers). Debt settlement involves coming to an agreement with your lender to pay an amount less than what’s owed. If you can’t negotiate a decrease in your credit card debt, you can consider taking out a personal loan or opening a zero-interest credit card to transfer your balance and pay off your debt.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (9)

Pros

  • Debt settlement negotiations allow you to reduce the amount of debt owed.
  • Credit card refinancing may be available at a lower interest rate, saving you money in the long term.
  • A consolidation loan simplifies your finances by reducing several credit card payments to just one monthly payment.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (10)

Cons

  • Debt settlement companies may charge hefty fees and could negatively impact your credit score.
  • If you don’t take quick action with a debt consolidation loan, your credit card payments may become overdue, hurting your credit score.

Pros and cons of debt forgiveness

While debt forgiveness can offer relief from overwhelming financial burdens, it’s essential to understand the potential benefits and drawbacks before you choose this path.

Benefits of debt forgiveness

Debt forgiveness offers several advantages that can provide much-needed relief to individuals struggling with overwhelming financial burdens.

  • It offers a bankruptcy alternative, allowing individuals to resolve their debts without the expenses and long-term consequences associated with filing for bankruptcy.
  • Forgiven debt often means paying less than the initial amount owed, saving borrowers money in the long run.
  • Debt forgiveness can eliminate the stress of dealing with aggressive debt collectors, providing a sense of relief and allowing you to focus on rebuilding your financial health.
  • By negotiating reduced settlements or payment plans, debt forgiveness empowers you to pay off your debt more quickly.

Downsides of debt forgiveness

Having less debt to pay off certainly sounds appealing. However, there are some negative repercussions to consider:

  • Debt forgiveness may negatively affect credit scores, making it challenging to obtain future loans or credit.
  • Forgiven debt of more than $600 may be considered taxable income, potentially resulting in a hefty tax bill.
  • Engaging with debt relief companies could lead to additional fees, exacerbating financial difficulties.
  • Debt settlement scams can trap vulnerable customers by promising unrealistic results, further complicating their financial situation.

Do debt relief programs hurt your credit?

While debt relief programs can provide much-needed relief, they may temporarily hurt your credit score. However, timely payments and responsible financial management can help mitigate any negative effects, ultimately leading to improved credit over time.

Alternatives to debt forgiveness

If you don’t qualify for debt forgiveness or simply find it’s not a good fit, there are alternative debt management options to help you repay and manage your debts:

  • Debt consolidation: Debt consolidation is the process of merging multiple debts into a single loan, typically with a lower interest rate. This can simplify payments and potentially reduce overall debt.
  • Debt settlement: Negotiating with your creditors to settle debts for less than the total amount owed can provide immediate relief, albeit with potential credit repercussions. You can do this yourself or through a debt relief company.
  • Credit counseling: Seeking guidance from accredited credit counseling agencies can help you create realistic budgeting strategies and debt management plans.
  • Credit repair: If you think you can manage your debt if you have a better credit score,
  • File for bankruptcy: In extreme cases where debt is insurmountable, filing for bankruptcy may offer a fresh start by liquidating assets or establishing a repayment plan.

The bottom line

Debt forgiveness can be a lifeline for individuals struggling with overwhelming debt. By understanding how it works, exploring the available options, and weighing the pros and cons, you can make informed decisions about your financial future.

If you’re facing financial hardship, don’t hesitate to seek assistance from reputable sources, such as financial advisors or nonprofit organizations. With perseverance and careful financial management, you can overcome debt and regain your financial footing.

Why Debt Forgiveness Is Not As Forgiving As It Looks | Bankrate (2024)

FAQs

What are the disadvantages of debt forgiveness? ›

Downsides of debt forgiveness

However, there are some negative repercussions to consider: Debt forgiveness may negatively affect credit scores, making it challenging to obtain future loans or credit. Forgiven debt of more than $600 may be considered taxable income, potentially resulting in a hefty tax bill.

Why is debt relief bad? ›

Creditors are not legally required to settle for less than you owe. Stopping payments on your bills (as most debt relief companies suggest) will damage your credit score. Debt settlement companies can charge fees. If over $600 is settled, the IRS will view this debt as a taxable income.

Is debt forgiveness legit? ›

While it's highly unlikely that any credit card company will forgive 100% of your debt without it being part of a bankruptcy, you may be able to negotiate a settlement with your lenders in which they forgive a percentage of the balance you owe.

Do credit card companies ever forgive debts? ›

Credit card companies rarely forgive your entire debt. But you might be able to settle the debt for less and get a portion forgiven. Most credit card companies won't provide forgiveness for all of your credit card debt. But they will occasionally accept a smaller amount to settle the balance due and forgive the rest.

Is it a good idea to go with a debt relief program? ›

Debt relief will also often give you a fixed payment plan and a set payoff date, which can also make it worth considering — as streamlining your payments can make it easier to manage while helping you save money on interest. "One of the biggest advantages of going through a debt relief program is the savings.

What are the best debt relief companies? ›

Summary: Best Debt Relief Companies of May 2024
CompanyForbes Advisor RatingBBB Rating
Money Management International4.0A+
CuraDebt3.9A+
New Era Debt Solutions3.8A+
Freedom Debt Relief3.7A+
3 more rows
May 1, 2024

What is the catch with debt relief? ›

Warning: There could be tax consequences for debt forgiveness. If a portion of your debt is forgiven by the creditor, it could be counted as taxable income on your federal income taxes. You may want to consult a tax advisor or tax attorney to learn how forgiven debt affects your federal income tax.

Why is bad debt so bad? ›

Debt might be considered bad if it's difficult to repay or doesn't offer long-term benefits—think loans with high interest rates or unfavorable repayment terms, for example. If you're considering taking on debt, it might help to consider what it could do to your debt-to-income (DTI) ratio.

Is debt forgiveness the same as bad debt? ›

Writing off a debt as bad is not the same as waiving or forgiving a debt. There are different tax consequences for debt forgiveness or waiver and there may also be tax consequences for the debtor.

Are banks really writing off credit card debt? ›

Typically, a credit card company will write off a debt when it considers it uncollectable. In most cases, this happens after you have not made any payments for at least six months. However, each creditor has a different process for determining whether a debt is uncollectable.

Can I get a government loan to pay off debt? ›

While there are no government debt relief grants, there is free money to pay other bills, which should lead to paying off debt because it frees up funds. The biggest grant the government offers may be housing vouchers for those who qualify. The local housing authority pays the landlord directly.

How can the elderly stop paying credit cards debts? ›

Option Two: File a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. The “upside” of proceeding in this fashion is that your Chapter 7 Trustee will not be able to reach your assets either, and the stress associated with harassing phone calls and other collection activities will stop immediately upon the filing of your bankruptcy petition.

Is it true that after 7 years your credit is clear? ›

Highlights: Most negative information generally stays on credit reports for 7 years. Bankruptcy stays on your Equifax credit report for 7 to 10 years, depending on the bankruptcy type. Closed accounts paid as agreed stay on your Equifax credit report for up to 10 years.

Does debt forgiveness ruin your credit? ›

Negative impact to your credit score: Unfortunately, most types of debt forgiveness, including filing for bankruptcy, seeking a short sale for your home or applying for credit card forgiveness, will hurt your credit score.

Can I ask my creditors to write off my debt? ›

The people you owe usually only agree to write off debts in the most serious cases. They will ask for proof of your illness or injury. They might agree not to contact you for a while, even if they do not write it off. They may also be able to help you if you are dealing with a mental health issue.

Do it yourself debt relief pros and cons? ›

Understanding the Process of Debt Settlement
Pros of DIY Debt SettlementCons of DIY Debt Settlement
Total control of the processTotal responsibility for the process
Potential faster repayment of debtRequires more time, patience, effort, and negotiating skill than you may have at hand
2 more rows

What are the pros and cons of participating in a loan forgiveness and repayment program? ›

The pros and cons of student loan forgiveness
  • Con: Forgiving debt isn't fair to people who've already made their payments. ...
  • Pro: Debt forgiveness is the empathetic solution. ...
  • Con: Student loan forgiveness could worsen inflation. ...
  • Pro: An imperfect solution is better than nothing.

Does cancellation of debt affect your credit? ›

If you are facing serious financial difficulties, you may be able to get all or a portion of your debts canceled. However, debt cancellation can have long-term negative consequences to your credit, and you should consider it only when there are no better alternatives for you.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Mr. See Jast

Last Updated:

Views: 5335

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mr. See Jast

Birthday: 1999-07-30

Address: 8409 Megan Mountain, New Mathew, MT 44997-8193

Phone: +5023589614038

Job: Chief Executive

Hobby: Leather crafting, Flag Football, Candle making, Flying, Poi, Gunsmithing, Swimming

Introduction: My name is Mr. See Jast, I am a open, jolly, gorgeous, courageous, inexpensive, friendly, homely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.